Working with Unsafe -

# Working with Unsafe

Rust generally only gives us the tools to talk about Unsafe Rust in a scoped and binary manner. Unfortunately, reality is significantly more complicated than that. For instance, consider the following toy function:

    # #![allow(unused_variables)]
    #fn main() {
    fn index(idx: usize, arr: &[u8]) -> Option<u8> {
        if idx < arr.len() {
            unsafe {
                Some(*arr.get_unchecked(idx))
            }
        } else {
            None
        }
    }
    #}

This function is safe and correct. We check that the index is in bounds, and if it is, index into the array in an unchecked manner. But even in such a trivial function, the scope of the unsafe block is questionable. Consider changing the `<` to a `<=`:

    # #![allow(unused_variables)]
    #fn main() {
    fn index(idx: usize, arr: &[u8]) -> Option<u8> {
        if idx <= arr.len() {
            unsafe {
                Some(*arr.get_unchecked(idx))
            }
        } else {
            None
        }
    }
    #}

This program is now unsound, and yet we only modified safe code. This is the fundamental problem of safety: it's non-local. The soundness of our unsafe operations necessarily depends on the state established by otherwise "safe" operations.

Safety is modular in the sense that opting into unsafety doesn't require you to consider arbitrary other kinds of badness. For instance, doing an unchecked index into a slice doesn't mean you suddenly need to worry about the slice being null or containing uninitialized memory. Nothing fundamentally changes. However safety isn't modular in the sense that programs are inherently stateful and your unsafe operations may depend on arbitrary other state.

This non-locality gets much worse when we incorporate actual persistent state. Consider a simple implementation of `Vec`:

    use std::ptr;

    // Note: This definition is naive. See the chapter on implementing Vec.
    pub struct Vec<T> {
        ptr: *mut T,
        len: usize,
        cap: usize,
    }

    // Note this implementation does not correctly handle zero-sized types.
    // See the chapter on implementing Vec.
    impl<T> Vec<T> {
        pub fn push(&mut self, elem: T) {
            if self.len == self.cap {
                // not important for this example
                self.reallocate();
            }
            unsafe {
                ptr::write(self.ptr.offset(self.len as isize), elem);
                self.len += 1;
            }
        }
        # fn reallocate(&mut self) { }
    }

    # fn main() {}

This code is simple enough to reasonably audit and informally verify. Now consider adding the following method:

    fn make_room(&mut self) {
        // grow the capacity
        self.cap += 1;
    }

This code is 100% Safe Rust but it is also completely unsound. Changing the capacity violates the invariants of Vec (that `cap` reflects the allocated space in the Vec). This is not something the rest of Vec can guard against. It has to trust the capacity field because there's no way to verify it.

Because it relies on invariants of a struct field, this `unsafe` code does more than pollute a whole function: it pollutes a whole module. Generally, the only bullet-proof way to limit the scope of unsafe code is at the module boundary with privacy.

However this works perfectly. The existence of `make_room` is not a problem for the soundness of Vec because we didn't mark it as public. Only the module that defines this function can call it. Also, `make_room` directly accesses the private fields of Vec, so it can only be written in the same module as Vec.

It is therefore possible for us to write a completely safe abstraction that relies on complex invariants. This is critical to the relationship between Safe Rust and Unsafe Rust.

We have already seen that Unsafe code must trust some Safe code, but shouldn't trust generic Safe code. Privacy is important to unsafe code for similar reasons: it prevents us from having to trust all the safe code in the universe from messing with our trusted state.

Safety lives!