Re: Mail archive search broken

[Jason Smethers <jason@xxxxxxxxxxxx>]

justin@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
> > Someone might want to take a look at the google search form on the mail
> > archive page: <http://leaf.dragonflybsd.org/mailarchive/>
> >
> > The WWW option is searching the entire internet, and the mail archive
> > option is search the entire dragonfly website.
>
>
> The WWW option is supposed to search the entire Internet.  The mail
> archive option searches everything on leaf.dragonflybsd.org, which will
> pull in things from user folders and so on.  Google's sitesearch function
> can't be restricted to a subset of a site, that I know of.  It's not
> perfect, but it is free.
>
> Putting together a new search function would be handy, using htdig or
> something similar - it's a project for anyone who wants it.


First, if I go to a website and they have a google search option, I 
expect the www option to implicitly mean search their website. I can go 
to google myself to search the Internet.

Second, when I see "dragonfly mail archives" and select it, I expect the 
search to be restricted to the mail archives, not the entire site. I do 
not want to receive man pages in the results.

Simply put, the descriptions do not match the expected behavior.


I personally do not like htdig. Its search results are usually marginal.

Since google seems to be restricted domain names, why not add an alias 
for the mail archive, such as mailarchive.dragonflybsd.org, and setup 
the google search option to search using that domain.


Thanks,
Jason